With the war in Ukraine entering another punishing winter, those delivering humanitarian aid are grappling with a harsh new calculus: how closely they can serve embattled communities without placing lives in unacceptable jeopardy. According to Matthias Schmale, the United Nations’ top humanitarian official in Ukraine, the stakes have grown as Russian attacks on civilians and energy infrastructure increase in frequency and ferocity, especially as cold weather approaches.

Attacks targeting Ukraine’s power grids and essential services have already stripped many communities of heat, water, and basic utilities, intensifying a humanitarian crisis that shows no sign of abating. Schmale recalls humanitarian teams meeting in Kherson bunker offices, planning the best strategies to support those refusing to abandon their homes near the frontline. But the same workers also face the urgent task of orchestrating evacuations—often at great personal risk—to rescue residents who are finally forced to flee as conditions worsen.

Frontline Ukrainian volunteers and staff, most of whom are nationals, bear the greatest risks. Their dedication, Schmale emphasizes, is often accompanied by humor and a sense of duty, but the dangers are ever-present. In one incident, a team had to run from drone attacks in Kherson while trying to visit a local bakery. Such episodes capture the daily vulnerability of aid workers who, by necessity, operate under the threat of violence.

Schmale argues that proximity is essential—not just for effective aid delivery but for understanding the deep ties that bind people to their homes. The decision to evacuate often turns not on safety alone but on whether families can bring their pets and farm animals, entwined with their sense of home and normalcy. This granular understanding can only come from consistent, empathetic presence amid hardship.

Yet, remaining close raises a vexing operational question: how much risk can organizations ethically transfer to national staff and partners? The impulse to step back when the danger becomes overwhelming sometimes leads officials to consider sensitive alternatives, such as handing operations over to the military—an option fraught with its own complications. Schmale underscores that humanitarian law must be respected, and new tools—including technology to defend against drones—are needed to keep workers safe.

Despite the unrelenting hazards, Schmale is resolute that the UN will maintain a core presence in Ukraine “for as long as that is physically possible.” The challenge, he underscores, lies in balancing the commitment to those most in need with an uncompromising responsibility for the safety of every worker. The unresolved question: as the risks escalate, how long can this delicate balance be sustained?