The California Supreme Court has declined to review the case of Jose Elias Aguilar, a man convicted of murder and other serious charges stemming from a harrowing 2020 carjacking that ended with the death of 13-year-old Isabella Cortes in Pico Rivera. The high court’s decision, made public on November 18, 2026, leaves intact Aguilar’s life sentence without the possibility of parole, as imposed after a December 2024 trial in Norwalk.
The incident unfolded on July 5, 2020, when Aguilar, then 32, carried out a spree of carjackings over the course of a week. According to court records and trial evidence detailed in the memo, Aguilar forcibly took a minivan already occupied by Cortes and her siblings. While attempting to escape the moving vehicle driven at high speed by Aguilar, Isabella jumped out, struck a fire hydrant, and suffered fatal injuries.
Aguilar was ultimately charged with first-degree murder, kidnapping for carjacking, attempted kidnapping for carjacking, carjacking, and corporal injury to a child. The jury at his December 2024 trial found him guilty on all counts and affirmed special allegations that the murder occurred during both a carjacking and a kidnapping.
After his conviction, Aguilar’s legal team pursued appeals, arguing that the jury instructions could have allowed for conviction on an invalid theory and that the evidence did not support several of the convictions. However, an appellate panel from California’s 2nd District Court of Appeal upheld the verdict in August 2026, firmly concluding that Aguilar’s actions directly caused Isabella’s death.
With the California Supreme Court’s decision not to reconsider the case, the appellate ruling stands, cementing Aguilar’s life sentence. As of the latest reports, Aguilar remains incarcerated at the California Men’s Colony in San Luis Obispo.
Legal experts suggest Aguilar’s remaining options for challenging his conviction are now limited to potential federal habeas proceedings or similar extraordinary remedies. The case underscores the severe penalties for carjacking involving injury or death in California, a state where such crimes have consistently attracted strong judicial sanction.
There have been no publicly reported ongoing developments or conflicting accounts about the case. Advocacy organizations and the victim’s family have not released recent statements in response to the Supreme Court’s decision.