As diplomats and defense experts from more than 120 nations convened in Geneva on Monday, calls for urgent action resonated across the UN chamber. At issue: whether machines should ever hold the power of life and death in war. United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres pressed delegates to launch negotiations for a legally binding treaty restricting – and in certain cases banning – so-called ‘killer robots’, also known as lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS).

The gathering marks the 7th Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, the treaty responsible for tackling the humanitarian fallout of landmines, incendiary arms, and explosive remnants over the past forty years. But autonomous weapons – which can operate or select targets without direct human intervention – present new, complex challenges, Guterres stressed. “Even war has limits,” he warned, urging states to seize the moment for “clear prohibitions and restrictions” before such technology spreads further.

The Secretary-General’s warning follows a forceful appeal from UN human rights chief Volker Türk issued just days earlier. Türk cited the accelerating pace of weapons automation and the risk of such arms becoming widely accessible, arguing, “A machine must never have the power to decide whether a human being survives or dies.” He called for bans on any autonomous weapons that independently target people, and on any system whose functions cannot be fully explained or controlled by humans. Underlining legal and ethical stakes, Türk insisted human judgment cannot be replaced: machines lack the ability to weigh context or humanity as required by international law.

Global consensus on the issue remains elusive. Last December, 152 UN member states backed a General Assembly resolution affirming that lethal autonomous weapons must comply with the established laws of war; four nations opposed and eleven abstained. However, there is still no agreement on a specific new treaty – or even whether it should be legally binding. As the Geneva talks open, the absence of a common text or timeline underscores the diplomatic challenge ahead.

Alongside the core debate on AI weaponry, the conference is also set to review the humanitarian impacts of landmines and other emerging forms of warfare not yet addressed by existing conventions, a task organized by the UN Office for Disarmament Affairs. With 128 nations formally bound to the current Convention, the outcome of this week’s discussions could define the next chapter in international law governing conflict – or reveal widening fault lines between technological capacity and humanitarian restraint.