The South Dakota Supreme Court has reversed a lower court’s judgment in a closely watched dispute involving Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida, Inc. and its former pastor Mario Torres, reviving a case over the fate of $223,000 withdrawn from the church’s bank account. The Court ruled on November 11, 2026, that factual questions need a fuller hearing, particularly concerning allegations that the Church may have misrepresented a donor’s intentions.

At the center of the legal fight is a set of dramatic events in 2022, when church member Alex Cooper Vasquez wrote three $300,000 checks totaling $900,000 at a fundraising event. One check was clearly made out to the Church, while two others—left with the payee lines blank—were delivered in sealed envelopes to two pastors, including Torres. Torres deposited his check into the Church’s account, then withdrew $223,000, transferring it to his personal account and contending it was intended as a personal gift from the donor.

The Church responded by suing Torres for conversion and breach of fiduciary duty, claiming that once donated and deposited, the funds belonged to the Church. Torres countered with his own claims, alleging that Church leaders had falsely represented the donor Vasquez’s wishes and committed fraud.

The initial trial court sided with the Church, finding that blank checks were not legally valid gifts and that all funds in the parish account were Church property. But the Supreme Court’s decision has upended that outcome—judges concluded that real questions remain about the donor’s intent and whether Church representatives misrepresented that intent to claim the deposited funds. The court cited longstanding state precedent that delivery of a blank check does not in itself constitute a completed gift, and declined to apply religious immunity doctrines (the so-called ecclesiastical abstention doctrine), ruling that the case rests on secular rather than internal church matters.

The justices also reversed the award of prejudgment interest to the Church, noting recent changes in state law render such awards impermissible. With these technical and factual issues unresolved, the Supreme Court remanded the matter for a new trial or proceedings at the circuit court level. The question of whether Torres lawfully claimed the money—and whether the Church misrepresented the wishes of its donor—remains open.

The outcome could have wide implications for faith-based organizations and for fiduciaries handling church funds. Legal observers say the case may influence how large or ambiguous donations are administered and how courts intervene in church-related disputes that involve secular legal principles rather than religious doctrine.

The South Dakota Supreme Court’s published slip opinion in the case, “Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida, Inc. v. Mario Torres,” (2026 S.D. 57, Docket No. 31293) reflects the court’s careful attempt to balance legal precedent, the demands of secular justice, and the autonomy of religious organizations. As the case returns to the trial court, both parties will have a renewed chance to argue their understanding of the donor’s intent and the rightful ownership of the funds in question.