In one of New York State’s largest judicial districts, unofficial results from the November 3, 2026, elections show Republicans poised to claim a majority of the four available Supreme Court judgeships, with the final outcome awaiting state certification. According to preliminary data from multiple independent election trackers, including poliwave.com and theballotbrief.com, Republicans Kate Hogan, Tom Buchanan (incumbent), and Keith S. Massey Jr. each secured enough votes to be within the top four. They are joined by Democratic incumbent Christine M. Clark, with fellow Republican John T. Ellis just off the cutoff and another Democrat, Bradley M. Wanner, trailing behind.

The 4th Judicial District—covering 11 counties that comprise roughly a quarter of the state’s landmass, from Essex and Warren to Saratoga and St. Lawrence—has often seen competitive contests for these influential trial court positions. With all district voters selecting from a single ballot for the Supreme Court, campaigns in the region have traditionally emphasized geographic representation, courtroom experience, and party organization, given the sprawling constituency. This year, six major-party candidates vied for four seats in a climate shaped by ongoing debates over judicial impartiality and access to justice.

Unofficial Tallies Show Republican Advantage

Preliminary tabulations, sourced from live reporting engines, put Republican Kate Hogan atop the list with 19.1% of the vote (740,792 votes). She is closely followed by incumbent Republican Tom Buchanan at 17.1% (662,916), Keith S. Massey Jr. at 16.3% (630,276), and Democrat Christine M. Clark at 16.2% (625,968). Republican John T. Ellis, with 15.9% (615,240), and Democrat Bradley M. Wanner, with 15.2% (588,588), appear just below the cutoff for winning a bench seat.

Despite the clear Republican lead, no legal challenges or disputes have been reported and no major parties or candidates have formally contested the preliminary data, according to a review of public statements and published results as of November 15, 2026. The New York State Board of Elections must complete its canvassing and official certification process, which is expected to wrap up by December 15, per their standard schedule and confirmations reported by independent outlets.

Certification Outstanding in Closely Watched Race

The outcome holds significance not just for party control in a large swath of upstate New York, but for the judiciary’s regional balance and representation. The 4th District’s breadth—spanning urban centers such as Schenectady and Saratoga Springs to rural stretches of the Adirondacks—means each seat has wide impact on local justice administration. Past election cycles have seen similar multi-party splits amid consistently high turnout for judicial races, reflecting engaged interest in the local court system.

With the result still unofficial, observers note that certification is largely procedural, provided no discrepancies emerge. As of now, the process appears on track and no reason for significant delay is apparent, according to the Board of Elections’ communications and reporting by civic monitoring groups following the canvass.

Should the initial trends hold through certification, the 4th Judicial District will begin 2027 with a court bench majority shaped by this unusual partisan split—three Republican and one Democratic jurists chosen by the electorate, pending formal validation in the weeks ahead.