New York State lawmakers have introduced bills seeking to ban the use of several food additives—including the coloring agent Red 3, preservative propylparaben, and flour treatment potassium bromate—from foods and beverages sold in the state, intensifying a debate about food safety standards in the United States.

The proposed legislation, advanced by Assemblymember Dr. Anna Kelles and Senator Brian Kavanagh (A6424A/S6055B), would prohibit products containing a total of seven additives. This effort closely follows actions taken in California in 2023, where lawmakers voted to ban Red 3, potassium bromate, propylparaben, and brominated vegetable oil (BVO) by 2027.

Growing State-Level Momentum

While the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not banned these substances outright in food, concerns have mounted over their safety due to evidence from animal studies and bans already in place in the European Union. For example, Red 3—also called erythrosine—was banned by the FDA from use in cosmetics in 1990 following research that linked it to thyroid tumors in rats. Potassium bromate is seen as a potential carcinogen based on animal testing, and propylparaben has raised alarms as a potential endocrine disruptor. Nonetheless, these additives remain permitted in many food products nationwide.

Backers of the New York legislation point to gaps in federal oversight and cite California’s move as a precedent. If enacted, New York’s restrictions would take effect in 2025, accelerating the timeline adopted by California. Four of the targeted additives—azodicarbonamide, BVO, potassium bromate, and Red 3—are already banned throughout the European Union, while butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), included in the New York bill, is not currently outlawed there.

Industry Pushback and Public Advocacy

Historically, food industry groups have pushed back against state-level bans, arguing that current FDA assessments deem these additives safe at permitted levels and warning of inconsistent regulations that might disrupt interstate commerce. Conversely, consumer advocacy groups like the Environmental Working Group and Center for Science in the Public Interest have campaigned for state action, highlighting scientific studies and the fact that many food brands already offer additive-free alternatives overseas.

As of March 5, 2024, the New York bills remained in committee, with additional hearings and amendments likely before any floor vote. The current legislative push reflects a growing trend of states using their authority to tighten food safety rules in the absence of broad federal prohibitions.

Uncertain Future

The fate of New York’s proposal will be watched closely by policymakers, the food industry, and health advocates nationwide. A successful ban in Albany would signal further divergence in food regulation between the states and federal government, with potential ripple effects for national food policy and consumer products.

With rising consumer scrutiny and legislative momentum in multiple states, the debate over food additives in the U.S. appears unlikely to subside anytime soon.