An eerie discovery four years ago in Placer County has culminated in the arrests of a mother and daughter, who authorities say are linked to the killing of 73-year-old Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. Detectives say the case had gone cold—until forensic genetic genealogy provided the breakthrough needed to identify the dismembered victim and tie his immediate family to the crime.

On September 28, 2022, a woman walking her dog stumbled upon a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill containing a severely decomposed human head. Efforts by Placer County Sheriff’s investigators, together with forensic analysts at California State University, Chico, initially failed to identify the victim. Months of investigation passed with scarce progress.

The trail finally advanced in January 2024 when DNA from the remains was submitted to Othram Labs, a private forensic company specializing in genetic genealogy. This technique generated a genealogical profile that led authorities to identify the victim as Paul Fitzmaurice Jr., a Citrus Heights resident. Investigators discovered that no missing-persons report had ever been filed for Fitzmaurice. According to law enforcement, he lived with his wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, and his daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, up to his disappearance.

The investigation revealed further troubling allegations. Officials say Gwenn and Mary Fitzmaurice failed to report Paul’s death, allegedly maintaining the illusion that he was alive to continue collecting his Social Security and CalPERS retirement checks. Detectives, with FBI assistance, executed a search warrant at the Fitzmaurice home in Citrus Heights on November 17, arresting both women. Mary faces a murder charge while Gwenn is accused of acting as an accessory.

Authorities have not released details about the suspected motive or the exact circumstances of the killing, and they declined to state where they believe the murder took place. The case remains active, with investigators keeping open the possibility of further charges or revelations as forensic analysis and interviews continue.

This investigation spotlights the growing power of genetic genealogy to solve cold cases. Over the past few years, partnerships between California law enforcement, universities, and private labs have helped close dozens of once-mysterious homicides. Yet, for neighbors and relatives of Paul Fitzmaurice Jr., the discovery of his fate—and the allegations against his family—leave behind new questions in the wake of hard-won answers.