A chilling four-year-old murder case in Northern California has taken a dramatic turn with the arrest of two Citrus Heights women, the wife and daughter of the victim, after authorities linked them to the 2022 discovery of a severed head found in Foresthill.

On September 28, 2022, investigators responded to the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, where a trash bag containing a decomposed human head was discovered. The grisly find left authorities struggling to even determine the victim’s identity, as no recent missing persons reports matched the remains. The case remained stagnant for over a year.

It wasn’t until January 2024 that forensic genetic genealogy—a rapidly advancing investigative technique—enabled authorities to identify the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73, of Citrus Heights. Fitzmaurice had been living with his wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, and their daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, at a home on Lichen Drive before his disappearance. No missing persons report had ever been filed on his behalf.

On November 17, 2026, Placer County Sheriff’s Office detectives executed a search warrant at the family residence. Both women were taken into custody: Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, on suspicion of murdering her father, and Gwenn Fitzmaurice, 75, as an alleged accessory to the crime. Authorities allege Mary killed her father in their home and, together with Gwenn, attempted to cover up the crime by disposing of his remains in a remote area of neighboring Placer County.

Beyond the murder investigation, detectives say they discovered evidence the pair continued collecting Paul Fitzmaurice’s Social Security and CalPERS pension payments after his death, suggesting possible financial motives and opening the case to potential fraud charges. The mother and daughter, both expected to be arraigned this week, face legal scrutiny amid ongoing efforts to build a comprehensive case.

The motive behind the alleged murder remains undisclosed, and authorities have not specified whether additional remains have been located or how Paul Fitzmaurice’s head was transported to Foresthill. The case has highlighted law enforcement’s increasing reliance on and success with forensic genetic genealogy in cracking previously unsolved crimes, underscoring the years-long challenge of bringing closure to complex investigations with limited physical evidence.

Both women remain in custody as the investigation continues. Officials caution that further charges may be forthcoming after review of the illegal collection of state and federal benefit payments following Fitzmaurice’s death.