The long-running legal saga surrounding the 2017 death of 7-year-old Sanaa Cunningham in Goodyear, Arizona is set for another chapter, as a Maricopa County judge has denied the defense’s bid to dismiss charges against her parents, Lisa and Germayne Cunningham. The couple will face a fresh trial in April 2027, following a mistrial this past spring caused by evidence handling failures within the local police department.

The renewed prosecution comes nearly a decade after Sanaa’s death, which authorities allege was the result of actions by her parents. The Cunninghams, who had been on trial since September 2025, saw proceedings halted in March 2026 after significant problems surfaced involving the Goodyear Police Department’s management of key evidence — particularly gaps in the documented chain of custody for the defendants’ cell phones and other materials.

Detective Noah Yeo testified that he uncovered discrepancies in evidence logs months before trial but didn’t reveal the issue until January 2026. The Goodyear Police Department admitted to these lapses and announced an external review and reforms to its evidence protocols. The disruption prompted Judge Patricia Starr to declare a mistrial in April, releasing the Cunninghams from custody under electronic monitoring as the court considered next steps.

In a November 2026 decision, Judge Starr refused the defense’s motion to dismiss the case outright, siding with prosecutors who argued that a new trial could address any disadvantage from the evidence mishandling. The defense, for its part, maintains that the controversy undermines the case’s integrity and that information about the evidence problems was withheld, claims the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office has disputed publicly.

The upcoming trial will not only test the prosecution’s ability to prove its case after years of legal turbulence—it will also put recent reforms at the Goodyear Police Department under fresh scrutiny. With unresolved questions about past practices and the reliability of the evidence, both the outcome of the retrial and the department’s standing in future prosecutions may hinge on proceedings set to begin next spring.