The City of Fontana has agreed to pay more than $3.2 million to the family of Jaime Valdez, a man shot and killed by a city police officer while experiencing a mental health crisis in November 2023. The settlement, finalized in early November 2026, concludes a lawsuit that drew renewed focus to police protocols in responding to individuals in distress and spurred calls for reform.

According to official records, Officer Alex Yanez responded to a 911 call on the evening of November 11, 2023, concerning Valdez, who was reported as unarmed and behaving erratically in the driveway of his uncle’s home. Police department documents state that, after Yanez identified himself and attempted to communicate, Valdez failed to follow several commands. An initial attempt to subdue Valdez with a Taser proved ineffective. Police reports allege that Valdez reached for Yanez’s handgun and managed to grab the Taser, prompting Yanez to fire his weapon three times—striking Valdez once in the head and twice in the left shoulder.

Valdez died at the scene. His mother and two daughters filed a lawsuit against the city and the officer the following year, alleging that the use of deadly force was excessive and that proper de-escalation was never attempted. Legal documents from the family emphasized Valdez’s history of mental illness and accused city police of a systemic failure to respond compassionately to people in crisis.

In February 2024, the California Department of Justice completed an independent investigation, in accordance with state law requiring the review of police shootings involving unarmed civilians. The state’s findings concluded there was insufficient evidence to pursue criminal charges against Officer Yanez. However, the Department recommended that the police assessment and documentation policies be improved. The city, for its part, admitted no wrongdoing in the settlement but cited the risks and costs of a lengthy trial as its rationale for agreeing to the payout.

Officer Yanez remains on duty with Fontana Police, with no public disciplinary action on record as of this report. The incident, however, spurred broader response: Fontana Police have since expanded their Community Outreach and Support Team (C.O.A.S.T.), integrating mental health professionals and first responders to intercept and handle crisis calls with the aim of prevention and support—initiatives city officials say are meant to reduce the risk of violent encounters.

This settlement follows a number of similar cases across California where families of individuals killed during police encounters over mental health issues have received significant compensation. In September 2026, an $11 million jury award was issued for the family of Wilver Blanco, who died in a comparable incident involving LAPD officers.

Advocacy groups and legal experts argue these cases reflect a critical and ongoing need to reexamine the intersection of public safety and mental health. As cities like Fontana alter their protocols in the wake of tragedy, the question remains: Will these reforms be enough to prevent future deaths?