The killing of Kurt Van Dyke, a beloved California expat and pioneering surfer in Costa Rica, has taken a dramatic turn as investigators arrested his longtime girlfriend and a second suspect, charging both in connection with his February 2026 death. Authorities now believe that the crime was an inside job, contradicting earlier descriptions of a violent home invasion.

Van Dyke, 66, was discovered dead on February 14, 2026, in his residence in Hone Creek, a coastal town near Cahuita in Talamanca. Hidden under a bed and covered with a sheet, his body showed multiple stab wounds and evidence of asphyxiation, according to reports from Costa Rican police (Los Angeles Times, latimes.com).

Initially, Van Dyke’s girlfriend, identified as Arroyo, gave a harrowing account to authorities: While she was showering, two armed men broke into their home, restrained her with plastic zip ties, and allegedly stole valuables along with her car. Arroyo survived the ordeal without physical harm, and the incident was broadly reported as a home robbery gone awry—until months later, when police findings cast doubt on this narrative (abc7news.com, abc7news.com).

Key Developments in the Investigation

Following months of review, Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ) arrested Arroyo and a 34-year-old local man named Gutiérrez on November 12, 2026. Investigators now allege that Arroyo conspired to let the perpetrators enter Van Dyke’s home. The theft of her vehicle, once seen as evidence of an opportunistic robbery, is now believed to have been staged: The car was later found undamaged nearby, undercutting claims of a desperate escape or chase (Los Angeles Times, latimes.com).

According to Costa Rican authorities, the pair are suspected but have not been convicted, and both have been transferred to the Public Prosecutor’s Office as of November 13. Prosecutors are currently determining whether to file formal charges. Investigators continue to pursue two additional suspects believed to have participated actively in the fatal attack, but their identities and whereabouts remain unknown (thedailycrime.org, thedailycrime.org).

A Shifting Narrative and Ongoing Uncertainty

The unraveling of Arroyo’s initial account, coupled with alleged evidence of her planning role, has left both the local expat community and Van Dyke’s family reeling. Van Dyke, originally from Santa Cruz, California, gained fame in both countries as a surfer known as the “King” of Salsa Brava and as owner of Hotel Puerto Viejo (Los Angeles Times).

The case remains open, with Costa Rican authorities emphasizing that the investigation is ongoing and that the accused are presumed innocent pending judicial proceedings. As the search for further suspects continues, questions linger around the precise motives and planning behind the killing, which has shocked both the tight-knit surf scene and local tourism sector along the country’s Caribbean coast.