The Cincinnati Reds have emerged as one of the primary suitors for free agent right-hander Dustin May, as the club faces mounting pressure to address a depleted starting rotation ahead of the 2027 Major League Baseball season. May’s market has accelerated since he declined a $20 million mutual option with the Milwaukee Brewers for 2027, promptly seeking opportunities elsewhere after contributing to the Brewers’ 2026 World Series run.
Former MLB general manager Jim Bowden reported that the Reds are among several clubs expressing interest in May, a 29-year-old with experience on four major league rosters and a career 4.12 ERA across seven seasons. According to multiple reports, the Chicago Cubs, Washington Nationals, Baltimore Orioles, San Francisco Giants, Cleveland Guardians, Miami Marlins, Chicago White Sox, and Toronto Blue Jays are also in the mix, setting the stage for a competitive free-agency sweepstakes.
The Reds’ urgency stems largely from the loss of Hunter Greene, who is expected to miss the entire 2027 campaign following Tommy John surgery. With the team finishing 75-87 in 2026 and missing the playoffs, management has made bolstering the pitching staff its top offseason priority. May’s profile is intriguing for Cincinnati; he logged 31 starts in 2026 with the Cardinals and Brewers, finishing 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA overall. While his brief tenure in Milwaukee saw a spike in his ERA (5.65 in 10 regular-season starts and 5.73 over five postseason outings), he remained an important contributor as the Brewers secured a championship.
May’s free agency is not without concern, as his recent career has been marked by significant injuries—including Tommy John surgery in 2021 and a flexor tendon/UCL revision in 2023—which led to missed time in 2024. Despite these setbacks, projections by FanGraphs and industry analysts suggest May could command a contract in the range of two years and $30 million, with contenders eyeing his upside if he can return to past form.
The Reds must weigh their pursuit of May against potential alternatives; free agent Brady Singer, noted for greater health and consistency, is also under consideration. However, May’s postseason experience—including his World Series contributions just this past October—may tip the scales as Cincinnati plots its offseason moves. According to Sports Illustrated, the front office is determined to construct a competitive rotation as it seeks to break its postseason drought and reassert itself in the National League Central.
The outcome of May’s free agency and the sweepstakes for his signature could determine whether the Reds’ ambitions for a turnaround in 2027 are realized, as the club faces both opportunity and risk in one of the hottest pitching markets of the winter.