The legal fight over Colorado’s expanded antidiscrimination law, which includes protections for individuals’ chosen names and pronouns, entered a new phase as the U.S. Supreme Court on November 16, 2026 declined to review challenges to a related legislative rule, leaving key questions for lower courts. The Tenth Circuit is now weighing arguments about whether the law compels speech in violation of the First Amendment.
At the heart of the controversy is Colorado House Bill 25-1312, enacted in May 2025. This measure amended the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act (CADA), making it unlawful for businesses to deny services based on gender identity or expression. It further prohibits businesses from refusing to use individuals’ self-identified names and pronouns, cementing protections for transgender and nonbinary residents.
Soon after the bill took effect, several individuals and advocacy groups challenged the law in federal court. They allege that requiring them to use pronouns and names that do not align with their beliefs about gender identity amounts to compelled speech—raising fundamental concerns about free speech rights under the First Amendment.
On September 25, 2026, U.S. District Judge Regina M. Rodriguez addressed three consolidated lawsuits attacking the law’s constitutionality. Judge Rodriguez ruled that three advocacy groups lacked the legal standing to sue, but allowed six individual plaintiffs—including physicians, a medical practice, a retailer, and a bookstore—to proceed with their claims. The court stopped short of ruling on the law’s merits and whether the pronoun provisions infringe on the First Amendment, emphasizing that these questions remain unresolved as the case moves forward.
The legal battle shifted to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, which heard oral arguments on November 13, 2026. During the hearing, judges questioned whether the challengers—represented by several conservative legal organizations—face genuine threats under the law, as none had yet been forced to violate their beliefs in the course of business. The core of the appellate review now centers on whether the plaintiffs have sufficient standing to pursue their constitutional claims.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Supreme Court on November 16 opted not to intervene in a separate but related matter, declining to hear advocacy groups’ challenge to a Colorado General Assembly rule barring ‘deadnaming’ or misgendering during legislative sessions. By turning down the appeal, the high court leaves current judicial findings undisturbed and signals that appeals in the main challenge will continue to wind through lower courts.
This litigation is among several nationwide to test the boundaries between state-mandated antidiscrimination protections and the free speech rights of those who oppose the use of chosen names and pronouns for transgender people. For Colorado, the immediate question for the Tenth Circuit—and potentially, eventually, the Supreme Court—will be whether HB25-1312’s protections come at the expense of constitutional freedoms, or whether civil rights laws can demand such accommodations without crossing the line into compelled speech.
As of now, the Colorado law remains in effect. All eyes are on the Tenth Circuit panel as it weighs arguments that could further shape the national conversation on civil rights and free expression.