Former President Donald Trump is set to test the courts’ boundaries on defamation as federal judges allowed his complaints against both The New York Times and the BBC to proceed, even as high-profile defamation verdicts continue to stand against him. The developments, unfolding in U.S. courts in mid-November 2026, could have far-reaching implications for the relationship between public figures and the media.
On November 19, a federal judge in Tampa partly cleared Trump’s $15 billion defamation suit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House to advance, letting seven specific claims—mainly about reports on Trump’s tax affairs and resulting investigations—move forward. While two counts were dismissed, the decision keeps alive the prospect of a courtroom battle over whether media accounts, and the publishing of statements about public figures, meet the demanding standards for actual malice set out in landmark cases like New York Times v. Sullivan. (signaldata.org)
Separately, a federal judge in Florida said a defamation suit brought by Trump against the BBC could proceed, finding that aside from one count under state unfair business laws, Trump’s claims about a BBC documentary are strong enough to be heard in court. (abcnews.com) The ruling focuses scrutiny again on whether global media can be sued under U.S. law for coverage that reaches American audiences.
Defamation Law Under Scrutiny
Trump’s legal campaign comes even as judgements against him—particularly those brought by writer E. Jean Carroll—have survived appeals all the way to the Supreme Court, with an $83.3 million defamation verdict confirmed in September 2025 and a $5 million judgment left in place as of June 2026. (abcnews.com) These verdicts highlight the potential liability faced by public figures who make defamatory statements, but the recent federal decisions in Florida show the courts are also open, in some circumstances, to hearing such figures’ claims against prominent news organizations.
The effect of these cases on U.S. defamation law remains uncertain, but experts note they could push courts to clarify or even adjust how the ‘actual malice’ standard applies, especially as digital and global media further complicate questions of legal jurisdiction and reputational harm. For now, Trump’s lawsuits represent a rare move by a former U.S. president to press wide-ranging defamation claims against news organizations, while simultaneously facing judgments for similar torts across the country.
Next Steps
As of November 2026, Trump’s legal victories mean parts of his lawsuits may proceed toward trial, where questions about the threshold for defamation—and the resilience of press protections—will be tested. The Carroll judgments remain final, having exhausted Trump’s appeals. The decisions come at a fraught moment for the intersection of free speech and reputation, with the next rounds of court proceedings poised to shape how defamation law balances those enduring American values.