In a decision that closes a long-unsolved disappearance but leaves open a host of legal and personal questions, a Shasta County judge on November 20, 2026, dismissed murder charges against Nicholas Allen Beery. The court found that Beery acted in self-defense when James “Jim” Redmill Sr. died in July 2021, marking a turning point in a case that had remained unresolved for more than five years.
Redmill was initially reported missing from his home in the remote Trinity Alps Preserve area of Shasta County on July 20, 2021. The trail went cold until May 2026, when investigators, acting on new information, searched Beery’s neighboring property. They found Redmill’s remains buried behind Beery’s residence on May 19, 2026, leading to Beery’s arrest and the filing of a murder charge, alongside allegations of drug- and firearm-related offenses.
The preliminary hearing became the pivotal moment in the murder case. According to court findings cited in regional reporting, the judge concluded that Beery had a reasonable belief that Redmill intended to use deadly force against him. California law allows deadly force in self-defense where such belief is both honest and reasonable. As a result, the murder charge was dismissed, and Beery was cleared of criminal liability for Redmill’s death after over half a year in custody.
The circumstances that led to the deadly encounter remain largely undisclosed, as the court’s ruling focused narrowly on the self-defense claim. Details about the interaction between Beery and Redmill on the property in 2021 were not the subject of broader court findings.
Beery’s legal troubles, however, are not over. As of November 21, he faces separate charges in Shasta County for multiple counts of possessing assault weapons, being a felon in possession of a firearm, and possession of a controlled substance for sale. Court records indicate Beery waived his right to a preliminary hearing on these new counts and is scheduled to return to court on December 4, 2026. The outcomes of these additional proceedings remain uncertain.
The case underscores the intricacies of self-defense laws in California, and how such defenses can lead to dismissal of even the gravest charges when the evidence supports a reasonable belief in imminent danger. Still, for the Redmill family and the Shasta County community, the resolution of the homicide charge leaves many unanswered questions about what happened on Wild Turkey Road that night in 2021.