A McMinnville homeowner’s plan to add a new garage has become the center of a criminal case after local police arrested contractor Johnathon R. Manco on fraud and theft charges. The arrest followed a prolonged dispute over a project that stalled, with the homeowner left substantially out of pocket and the garage still incomplete.

According to police investigation records summarized by The Lebanon Reporter, the homeowner entered into a contract with Manco in October 2021. The agreement called for the garage to be built in three stages for a total price of $98,000. Manco, a 40-year-old builder from Thorntown, reportedly completed only the initial phase—covering grading, excavation, and basic foundation work. However, the foundation was described by the homeowner as having been poured with sloppily constructed, inadequate, and “extremely crooked” forms.

Despite the lack of progress, Manco billed the homeowner more than $118,000 for deposits, blueprints, materials, and assorted project expenses—well above the original contract price. Investigators found that Manco could not provide receipts for various materials when requested. In August 2022, he sought an additional $6,800 for concrete pads, a charge that was not substantiated with documentation. Tensions escalated when Manco later demanded another $35,000 without any clear explanation, prompting the homeowner to contact police for guidance.

Police interviewed two independent contractors to assess the work done. Their estimates suggested the completed foundation phase should have cost just $17,500 to $18,800, a fraction of what the homeowner had paid. The discrepancy supported suspicions of fraudulent overcharging and led Detective Bradley Dunn to pursue criminal charges against Manco. Ultimately, Manco was arrested on October 10, 2023, facing counts of home improvement fraud and theft—both level 5 felonies under Oregon law.

At present, there is no information on whether the homeowner has been compensated or the contract resolved. The garage remains unfinished, and court proceedings are still pending. This arrest adds to a series of home improvement fraud incidents reported in Oregon in recent years, underscoring the importance of careful vetting and clear documentation when engaging contractors for major work.

Authorities recommend that homeowners in Oregon and elsewhere obtain multiple estimates, demand detailed written contracts, and keep records of all contractor payments. Police encourage reporting suspected fraud promptly to minimize losses and prevent repeat offenses in the community.